Submitted to the 2015 Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee
Instructions: To view public comments, start by choosing a topic or searching below — you can search by comment, organization, affiliation, or comment ID. The search word or phrase you enter must match completely to get a result. Searches are not case-sensitive.
INC NREF comments for the 2015 DGAC are attached.
Meat and poultry are an integral part of the American diet and the DGAC’s failure to recognize the role of lean meat as a component of a healthy eating pattern is concerning and ill considered. Indeed, the Committee’s last minute, back room decision to omit “lean meats” in a healthy pattern because of the purported absence of a definition of “lean meat” calls the Committee’s final recommendation into serious doubt. It also reflects either an astonishing lack of awareness of the scientific evidence or a callous disregard of that evidence, again calling into question the entirety of the recommendations submitted by the DGAC to the agencies. We encourage the agencies to include lean meat and poultry as a component of a healthy eating pattern. There is a risk that the foods chosen to replace lean meat and poultry will be less nutrient dense, especially as protein foods are the only foods consistently consumed at recommended levels. Reducing or limiting nutrient dense lean meats and increasing nutrient poor foods could have serious, adverse consequences. This risk would become real if the agencies incorporate this recommendation into federal policy because it will affect many programs, such as Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, WIC, National School Lunch Program, and other adult and child nutrition programs. Many Americans who use these programs are often at-risk nutritionally and losing a nutrient dense food option like lean meat and poultry could affect their intake of protein, iron, and other nutrients mentioned previously.The Committee’s recommendations are flawed in other respects. Sustainability is a complex issue that demands consideration of an array of scientific issues by experts in those fields. To recommend a “sustainable dietary pattern” when the very definition of sustainable is still at issue does a disservice to the importance of affordability, nutrient adequacy, safety and cultural relevance to the foods consumed by U.S. population. In addition, the recommendations fail to recognize that dietary guidance should be practical, affordable, and attainable. Recognizing and respecting the traditional eating patterns of the average American and providing guidance about how they can eat a more healthful diet within the context of their existing food choices is critical. * * * * *The meat and poultry industry is committed to providing safe, wholesome, and diverse nutritious products to consumers so they may make educated decisions in choosing the foods that best fit their personal lifestyle and family needs. These products include fresh, lean and processed meat and poultry products.
Thank you for this opportunity to submit comments for consideration by the 2015 Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee (DGAC). Please find the National Council of Farmer Cooperatives comments attached.
Please review literature regarding organic farming practices and its benefits over GMO for sustainability health. I'm attaching an article and I highly recommend the documentary The Future of Food. I realize that we have too many people in the FDA and EPA with Monsanto ties to solely address these concerns, but if other committees could work together to shed light on the dangers of GMO, we might be able to make amazing progress in protecting our food supply and the health of our citizens.
Recommended quantity and frequency of consumption of meat and dairy products should be decreased. Numerous studies show a dose response relationship between consumption of meat and dairy and risk of developing cancer, obesity, heart disease, and diabetes. Current levels of consumption are also environmentally unsustainable. Meat and dairy production are the nation's second largest source of methane emissions. The global warming potential of methane over the next 20 years, a critical time period to meet US GHG reduction goals, is 72 times greater than CO2. The projected public health impacts of failure to substantially reduce emissions are well documented.
Please see the attached comments submitted by the National Pork Producers Council. Thank you.
SC-2When considering the recommendation of whole grains, please look at some of the emerging science that addresses our body's response to gluten. The role of the gliadin protein and zonulin production that can lead to gut permeability, which is where our immune system mostly resides. It opens up more vulnerability to health problems. I'm attaching just one article. There are other texts available and more research needs to be conducted.
Beef and other forms of red meat have always and continue to be a sustainable and nutritious form of protein. Beef offers 27 cuts of lean beef that provide consumers with a healthy, nutritious form of protein. Please reconsider from the 7th meeting to keep lean meats as a core component of a healthy dietary pattern.
Get email updates
Language Assistance Available
Last updated: 2/23/2019
This site is coordinated by the Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion,
Office of the Assistant Secretary for Health, Office of the Secretary,
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion